feat: cases (reports, reviews, requests, appeals) and notifications (#9)
Release / release (push) Successful in 3s
CI / test (push) Successful in 17m26s
CI / image (apps/api/Dockerfile, t5de-hub-api) (push) Successful in 6s
CI / image (apps/web/Dockerfile, t5de-hub-web) (push) Successful in 15s

Phase 3, part 1 (`docs/design.md`, "Next"): cases and notifications. File blocks, API tokens and two-factor sign-in come as separate PRs.

**Cases**
- One queue (Console → Cases) for everything someone has to decide. Each case has:
  - a thread of notes, where internal notes are visible only to those deciding
  - an assignee (moderators assign cases to moderators)
  - a decision, Resolve or Decline, with a written resolution that the person who opened it sees
- **Reports:** anyone signed in can report a product or catalog from its page (the API also takes rooms and people).
  - Limits: 10 an hour, one open report per person and thing, and you can't report yourself.
  - Reports about a product go to the teams of the catalogs hosting it, as well as to moderators.
  - Only the reporter and moderators know who reported. The audit entry for a report isn't tagged with what it's about, so a product's creator can't find out from their audit log either.
- **Rating reviews:** a creator lowering a rating from adult to general now opens a review instead of being refused. The rest of the edit still saves. Resolving the review lowers the rating, recorded in the product's history.
- **Removal requests:** a catalog's team can ask moderators to remove a product it hosts, everywhere. Resolving it removes the product.
- **Deletion requests:** a catalog's owner asks for deletion from the catalog's console page, and a moderator decides, as agreed. Resolving it marks the catalog `deleted`: its key stops working, nothing is available from it, and its changes feed says so.
- **Appeals:**
  - From the audit log, the person an action affected can appeal it, once: their product removed, delisted or edited by someone else; their catalog suspended or rejected; a ban from a catalog or a declined request to join.
  - Another moderator decides. An admin may decide an appeal of their own action, and the audit log flags it.
  - Resolving records the decision; the moderator then undoes the action where it's done. For that, there's now a Restore for removed products (Console → Products, for moderators); the design mentioned one, but it was never built.
- The console shows a "Cases" tab, and a to-do with the number of open cases the person could decide.

**Notifications**
- A bell in the header with the unread count, and a notifications page with "Mark all as read".
- Each is also sent to the person's proxies over the realtime connection (`{"type": "notification"}`), so the client can show them later.
- They cover:
  - a moderator edited or locked your product, or undid a change (with the reason)
  - your product was removed or restored
  - your case was decided
  - someone replied on your case
  - a catalog decided your membership

**Also changed**
- A product's creator and moderators can now see it when it's adult, even without an adult account. Before, a creator who made their own product adult couldn't open its page any more, and neither could moderators. Getting and wearing adult products still need an adult account.

**Not done yet** (in `docs/console.md`): email notifications (the hub sends no email yet), canned reasons, private moderator notes on people and products, and second approval for the most destructive actions.

**Migration** `0012_cases`: the `moderation_case`, `case_note` and `notification` tables. (`case` is a reserved word in SQL, hence the table's name.)

**Checks**
- 51 API tests pass. The 7 in the new `cases.test.ts` cover:
  - who sees and decides each kind of case, and that the reporter stays private
  - rate limits and duplicate reports
  - the thread and internal notes, and assigning
  - what deciding each kind of case does
  - appeals by the person affected only, decided by another moderator
  - restoring a removed product
  - the notifications
- Type checks pass.
- On a local hub I went through every flow with the website's own forms: report from a product page; the catalog owner's note and decision; assigning, an internal note and a decision as admin; removal by a moderator, the creator's appeal from the audit log, the admin's decision and Restore; a creator's rating review and the decision lowering the rating; a deletion request and its decline; the notifications, the bell's count, and Mark all as read.
- Fixed along the way:
  - The catalog's team could see who reported.
  - A missing Resolve/Decline choice was treated as Decline; now it's refused.
  - The Unassign button sent the typed name instead of nothing.

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Phase 3, part 1 (`docs/design.md`, "Next"): cases and notifications. File blocks, API tokens and two-factor sign-in come as separate PRs.

**Cases**
- One queue (Console → Cases) for everything someone has to decide. Each case has:
  - a thread of notes, where internal notes are visible only to those deciding
  - an assignee (moderators assign cases to moderators)
  - a decision, Resolve or Decline, with a written resolution that the person who opened it sees
- **Reports:** anyone signed in can report a product or catalog from its page (the API also takes rooms and people).
  - Limits: 10 an hour, one open report per person and thing, and you can't report yourself.
  - Reports about a product go to the teams of the catalogs hosting it, as well as to moderators.
  - Only the reporter and moderators know who reported. The audit entry for a report isn't tagged with what it's about, so a product's creator can't find out from their audit log either.
- **Rating reviews:** a creator lowering a rating from adult to general now opens a review instead of being refused. The rest of the edit still saves. Resolving the review lowers the rating, recorded in the product's history.
- **Removal requests:** a catalog's team can ask moderators to remove a product it hosts, everywhere. Resolving it removes the product.
- **Deletion requests:** a catalog's owner asks for deletion from the catalog's console page, and a moderator decides, as agreed. Resolving it marks the catalog `deleted`: its key stops working, nothing is available from it, and its changes feed says so.
- **Appeals:**
  - From the audit log, the person an action affected can appeal it, once: their product removed, delisted or edited by someone else; their catalog suspended or rejected; a ban from a catalog or a declined request to join.
  - Another moderator decides. An admin may decide an appeal of their own action, and the audit log flags it.
  - Resolving records the decision; the moderator then undoes the action where it's done. For that, there's now a Restore for removed products (Console → Products, for moderators); the design mentioned one, but it was never built.
- The console shows a "Cases" tab, and a to-do with the number of open cases the person could decide.

**Notifications**
- A bell in the header with the unread count, and a notifications page with "Mark all as read".
- Each is also sent to the person's proxies over the realtime connection (`{"type": "notification"}`), so the client can show them later.
- They cover:
  - a moderator edited or locked your product, or undid a change (with the reason)
  - your product was removed or restored
  - your case was decided
  - someone replied on your case
  - a catalog decided your membership

**Also changed**
- A product's creator and moderators can now see it when it's adult, even without an adult account. Before, a creator who made their own product adult couldn't open its page any more, and neither could moderators. Getting and wearing adult products still need an adult account.

**Not done yet** (in `docs/console.md`): email notifications (the hub sends no email yet), canned reasons, private moderator notes on people and products, and second approval for the most destructive actions.

**Migration** `0012_cases`: the `moderation_case`, `case_note` and `notification` tables. (`case` is a reserved word in SQL, hence the table's name.)

**Checks**
- 51 API tests pass. The 7 in the new `cases.test.ts` cover:
  - who sees and decides each kind of case, and that the reporter stays private
  - rate limits and duplicate reports
  - the thread and internal notes, and assigning
  - what deciding each kind of case does
  - appeals by the person affected only, decided by another moderator
  - restoring a removed product
  - the notifications
- Type checks pass.
- On a local hub I went through every flow with the website's own forms: report from a product page; the catalog owner's note and decision; assigning, an internal note and a decision as admin; removal by a moderator, the creator's appeal from the audit log, the admin's decision and Restore; a creator's rating review and the decision lowering the rating; a deletion request and its decline; the notifications, the bell's count, and Mark all as read.
- Fixed along the way:
  - The catalog's team could see who reported.
  - A missing Resolve/Decline choice was treated as Decline; now it's refused.
  - The Unassign button sent the typed name instead of nothing.

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-authored-by: dhkatz <[email protected]>
This commit was merged in pull request #9.
This commit is contained in:
dhkatz authored and dhkatz committed 2026-11-05 22:14:08 +00:00
1 parent e07a6c6dac
commit 7299e10b08
33 files changed
+5228 -44

No files matched your search

+27 -3
View File
@@ -131,8 +131,22 @@ log), who opened it, a status (`open`, `resolved`, `declined`), an assignee, a r
| `catalog-deletion` | a catalog's owner (deleting goes to review for now) | moderators (`catalog:delete-review`) |
| `appeal` | the person affected by a removal, ban, delisting or decline (one per action) | a different moderator than the one who acted |
- People see cases they opened and cases about what they control (`case:read` at a covering scope).
- People see cases they opened or are assigned, and cases about what they control (`case:read` at a covering scope),
except reports: those only the reporter, the hosting catalogs' teams (reports about products) and moderators see,
and only the reporter and moderators see who reported (a report's audit entry isn't tagged with what it's about).
- Who decides: moderators, by the kind's permission (`case:resolve`; `product:rate-lower` for rating reviews,
`product:remove` for removal requests, `catalog:delete-review` for deletions); reports about a product also the
teams of the catalogs hosting it (`case:resolve` there). An appeal goes to another moderator than the one who acted;
an admin may decide one of their own, which the audit log flags (`ownAction`).
- Resolving a rating review lowers the rating (as an edit, in the product's history); a removal request removes the
product; a deletion request deletes the catalog (status `deleted`; its changes feed says so). Reports and appeals
record the decision, and the moderator acts where it's done: a removed product is restored (`POST
/api/v1/products/:id/unremove`), an edit undone from the history, a catalog reinstated, a member unbanned.
- Appealable actions: `product.remove`, `product.edit`/`lock`/`revert` by others (the creator), `catalog.delist`
(the product's creator), `catalog.suspend`/`reject` (the owner), `catalog.member_ban`/`member_decline` (the
person). The audit log marks the entries a person may appeal (`appealable`).
- Reports are limited per person (10 an hour), one open report per person and resource.
- Not built yet: canned reasons, moderator notes and second approval (below).
- **Canned reasons** (admins edit the list) for removals, bans, declines and edits; free text can be added.
- **Moderator notes**: private notes on people and products (`person:notes`), shown in the console only.
- **Second approval** for the most destructive actions: banning a person, removing a catalog and transferring a
@@ -144,6 +158,10 @@ log), who opened it, a status (`open`, `resolved`, `declined`), an assignee, a r
One table; shown on the website (a bell, unread count), on the proxy's realtime connection
(`{"type": "notification"}`, so the client can show them later), and by email for types the person opts into.
Built (2026-11-05): `product_edited` (by someone other than the creator, with the reason), `product_removed`,
`product_restored`, `case_decided`, `case_note`, `membership_decided`. Not yet: email (the hub sends none yet) and its
settings, and the import, grant, new-revision and request-digest types.
Types: a moderator edited your product (with the reason); a case about you or yours was opened or decided; your
membership request was decided; your import finished or failed; your catalog's deletion request was decided; a
product in your library has a new revision; a grant was made or withdrawn; someone requested your products
@@ -196,8 +214,14 @@ for meaning.
| `GET /api/v1/console/permissions?scope=...` | the person's permissions at a scope (the website uses it to show actions) |
| `GET /api/v1/console/audit?tag=&actor=&action=&from=&to=&q=` | entries the person may see, newest first |
| `GET /api/v1/console/stats?scope=&metric=&from=&to=` | `{series: [{day, value}]}` |
| `GET/POST /api/v1/cases`, `GET/PATCH /api/v1/cases/:id`, `POST /api/v1/cases/:id/notes` | cases |
| `GET /api/v1/notifications`, `POST /api/v1/notifications/read`, `GET/PUT /api/v1/notifications/settings` | notifications |
| `GET /api/v1/cases?status=&kind=&mine=1&before=&limit=` | `{cases, before, moderator}`: the cases the person may see (below), newest first |
| `POST /api/v1/cases` | `{kind, about?, catalog?, audit?, reason}` → 201 `{case}`. `report`: `about` names one product, catalog, room (its number) or person (username); 10 an hour (429 `rate_limited`), one open per person and resource (409 `already_reported`), not yourself. `removal-request`: `about.product`, hosted by `catalog`, whose `hosting:delist` the person needs. `appeal`: `audit`, an entry of an action that affected the person (409 `appealed` if they appealed it already) |
| `GET /api/v1/cases/:id` | `{case, notes, canDecide, canAssign}`; internal notes only for those deciding and moderators |
| `POST /api/v1/cases/:id/notes` | `{body, internal?}`: a note; the opener's reach the assignee and others' reach the opener as notifications (internal ones reach nobody) |
| `POST /api/v1/cases/:id/assign` | (`case:assign`) `{to: username or null}`: a moderator |
| `POST /api/v1/cases/:id/decide` | `{decision: "resolve" or "decline", resolution}`: by those who may decide it (below); resolving carries out a rating review, removal request or deletion request; the opener is told |
| `GET /api/v1/notifications?before=` | `{notifications: [{id, type, tags, data, at, read}], unread, before}`, newest first, 50 a page |
| `POST /api/v1/notifications/read` | `{ids?}` (all if left out) → `{unread}` |
| `GET/POST /api/v1/account/tokens`, `DELETE /api/v1/account/tokens/:id` | API tokens |
| `GET/PUT/DELETE /api/v1/roles/:scopeType/:scopeId/:person` | role assignments at a scope |
| `POST /api/v1/console/view-as/:person` | (admins) start viewing as someone, read-only |